Skip to content

πŸ” Duplicate Resource ReviewΒ #2492

Description

@github-actions

Summary


How to Use This Report

Review each group below. If the resources are intentionally separate, check the box to mark them as accepted. These will be excluded from future reports.


πŸ†• New Findings

Group 1: Planning Agents Cluster (extends #2411 Group 13)

  • Reviewed β€” these are intentionally separate
Resource Type Description
agents/plan.agent.md Agent Strategic planning and architecture assistant focused on thoughtful analysis before implementation.
agents/planner.agent.md Agent Generate an implementation plan for new features or refactoring existing code.
agents/implementation-plan.agent.md Agent Generate an implementation plan for new features or refactoring existing code.
agents/task-planner.agent.md Agent Task planner for creating actionable implementation plans.

Why flagged: All four agents focus on creating implementation plans or strategic planning before coding. planner.agent.md and implementation-plan.agent.md have identical descriptions (already flagged in #2411 Group 13). plan.agent.md and task-planner.agent.md are newly identified additions to this cluster that serve overlapping planning roles.


Group 2: C#/.NET Expert Agents

  • Reviewed β€” these are intentionally separate
Resource Type Description
agents/CSharpExpert.agent.md Agent An agent designed to assist with software development tasks for .NET projects.
agents/expert-dotnet-software-engineer.agent.md Agent Provide expert .NET software engineering guidance using modern software design patterns.

Why flagged: Both agents target .NET/C# software development as general-purpose coding experts. The name "C# Expert" and "Expert .NET software engineer" describe the same role. The descriptions both describe providing expert .NET guidance, with no clear distinction in scope.


Group 3: Accessibility β€” Agent + Runtime Agent + Instruction

  • Reviewed β€” these are intentionally separate
Resource Type Description
agents/accessibility.agent.md Agent Expert assistant for web accessibility (WCAG 2.1/2.2), inclusive UX, and a11y testing.
agents/accessibility-runtime-tester.agent.md Agent Runtime accessibility specialist for keyboard flows, focus management, dialog behavior, form errors, and evidence-backed WCAG validation in the browser.
instructions/a11y.instructions.md Instruction Comprehensive web accessibility standards based on WCAG 2.2 AA, with 38+ anti-patterns, legal enforcement context (EAA, ADA Title II), WAI-ARIA patterns, and framework-specific fixes.

Why flagged: All three resources target web accessibility (WCAG). The general accessibility.agent.md and a11y.instructions.md have significant overlap in scope. The runtime tester is more specialized (browser-based testing), but the general agent also covers a11y testing. Reviewers should confirm the runtime tester is sufficiently distinct.


♻️ Unresolved Carryovers from #2411

All 27 groups from #2411 remain unresolved. See that issue for full details.

# Group Resources
4 .NET MAUI β€” Agent + Instruction agents/dotnet-maui, instructions/dotnet-maui
5 .NET Upgrade β€” Agent + Instruction + Skill agents/csharp-dotnet-janitor, agents/dotnet-upgrade, agents/janitor, instructions/dotnet-upgrade, skills/dotnet-upgrade
6 AI Readiness Reporter agents/ai-readiness-reporter, skills/acreadiness-assess
7 Code Tour β€” Agent + Skill agents/code-tour, skills/code-tour
8 ADR Generator β€” Agent + Skill agents/adr-generator, skills/create-architectural-decision-record
9 Agent Governance / Safety β€” Agent + Instruction + Skill agents/agent-governance-reviewer, instructions/agent-safety, skills/agent-governance
10 AI Team β€” 3 Parallel Agents + Orchestration Skill agents/ai-team-dev, agents/ai-team-producer, agents/ai-team-qa, skills/ai-team-orchestration
11 Draw.io Diagram Generation skills/draw-io-diagram-generator, skills/drawio
12 Git Commit Message skills/conventional-commit, skills/git-commit, skills/commit-message-storyteller
13 C# Unit Testing Frameworks skills/csharp-mstest, skills/csharp-nunit, skills/csharp-tunit, skills/csharp-xunit
14 C#/.NET Janitor/Upgrade (agents only) agents/csharp-dotnet-janitor, agents/dotnet-upgrade, agents/janitor
15 Caveman Mode agents/caveman-mode, instructions/caveman-mode (identical descriptions)
16 Implementation Plan (agents only) agents/planner, agents/implementation-plan (identical descriptions) (see Group 1 above for full picture)
17 Quality Playbook agents/quality-playbook, skills/quality-playbook
18 Mentoring Juniors agents/mentoring-juniors, skills/mentoring-juniors
19 Doublecheck agents/doublecheck, skills/doublecheck
20 PRD agents/prd, skills/prd
21 Context7 agents/context7, instructions/context7
22 Markdown Accessibility agents/markdown-accessibility-assistant, instructions/markdown-accessibility
23 Gilfoyle Code Review agents/gilfoyle, instructions/gilfoyle-code-review
24 MS-SQL DBA agents/ms-sql-dba, instructions/ms-sql-dba
25 LinkedIn Post agents/linkedin-post-writer, skills/linkedin-post-formatter
26 MCP Expert Agents vs Instructions (10 langs) *-mcp-expert.agent.md Γ— 10 vs *-mcp-server.instructions.md Γ— 10
27 Suggest Awesome Resources skills/suggest-awesome-github-copilot-{agents,instructions,skills}
28 Copilot SDK Instructions (5 langs) instructions/copilot-sdk-{csharp,go,java,nodejs,python}
29 Power BI Agent+Instruction Pairs 3 pairs: data-modeling, DAX, visualization
30 Azure Functions vs Durable Functions C# instructions/azure-functions-csharp, instructions/azure-durable-functions-csharp
  • Group 4 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 5 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 6 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 7 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 8 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 9 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 10 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 11 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 12 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 13 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 14 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 15 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 16 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 17 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 18 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 19 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 20 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 21 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 22 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 23 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 24 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 25 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 26 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 27 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 28 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 29 reviewed β€” intentionally separate
  • Group 30 reviewed β€” intentionally separate

Generated by Duplicate Resource Detector Β· 84 AIC Β· βŒ– 6.44 AIC Β· ⊞ 5.9K Β· β—·

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions